Diminishing Depth to Water in Cambrian-Ordovician Arbuckle Group Disposal Wells in Kansas

  • K. David Newell Kansas Geological Survey
  • Shelby Peterie Kansas Geological Survey
  • Michael Killion Kansas Geological Survey
  • Brandy DeArmond Kansas Department of Health and Environment, Bureau of Environmental Remediation
  • Carrie Ridley Kansas Department of Health and Environment, Bureau of Water/Geology
  • Rolfe Mandel Kansas Geological Survey
  • Rex Buchanan Kansas Geological Survey
Keywords: Arbuckle Group, Kansas, Class I disposal well, Class II disposal well, hydrostatic surface, pieziometric surface, hydrostatic gradient, subsurface water chemistry, depth to water, subsurface flow

Abstract

Industrial and municipal wastewater and oilfield brines have been disposed of into the Cambrian-Ordovician Arbuckle Group for decades in Kansas and nearby states in the midcontinent United States. The industrial and municipal wastewater disposal wells (designated Class I disposal wells) are regulated by the Kansas Department of Health and Environment. The oilfield brines are disposed of in Class II disposal wells, which are regulated by the Kansas Corporation Commission. Annual testing of formation pressure and static fluid levels in Class I wells compose a body of data that is useful in monitoring movement of water and fill-up of Arbuckle disposal zones. In western Kansas, the depth to water in wells penetrating the Arbuckle can be several hundred to more than a thousand feet (305 m) below ground surface, but in parts of southern and southeastern Kansas, the depth to water locally can be less than 100 ft (31 m). Furthermore, most Class I wells indicate Arbuckle fluid levels in central and south-central Kansas are rising ~10 ft (~3 m) annually, suggesting that at current disposal rates, the Arbuckle may lose its capacity to accept wastewater under gravity flow in parts of the state in the next few decades, principally south-central and southeastern Kansas along the Oklahoma state line. At present in parts of six Kansas counties along the Oklahoma state line, low-density (~1.0 g/cc or slightly greater density) wastewater in a wellbore does not have a sufficient hydrostatic head by gravity alone to force its way into the more dense resident Arbuckle formation water.

In general, Arbuckle formation water flows west to east in Kansas. Arbuckle disposal wells in Kansas collectively dispose of ~800,000,000 barrels (~127,000,000 m3) of wastewater per year, although some of this is recycled from Arbuckle oil production. Declines in oil price since mid-2014 have resulted in less oilfield disposal in the Arbuckle since 2015. The number of Class I wells recording annual fluid rises have also declined since 2015, as has the median of their annual change in static fluid level, but overall, more Class I wells are still recording fluid rises. There is a poor correlation between changes in fluid levels in Class I wells and the volume of fluid disposed in them annually, thereby indicating that more regional characteristics may control water movement in the Arbuckle. More monitoring wells are needed to better understand the movement of water in the deep subsurface and to anticipate any potential problems that may occur with reduced disposal capacity and possible migration of fluids through unplugged or improperly plugged older wells.

References

Ansari, E., Bidgoli, T. S., and Hollenbach, A., 2019, Accelerated fill-up of the Arbuckle Group aquifer and links to US midcontinent seismicity: Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth, v. 124, no. 3, p. 2,670–2,683.

Byrnes, A. P., Franseen, E. K., and Steinhauff, D. M., 1999, Integrating plug to well-scale petrophysics with detailed sedimentology to quantify fracture, vug, and matrix properties in carbonate reservoirs — An example from the Arbuckle Group, Kansas: Kansas Geological Survey, Open-File Report 99-47, 3 sheets. http://www.kgs.ku.edu/PRS/Poster/1999/99-47/index.html

Cansler, J. R., and Carr, T. R., 2001, Paleogeomorphology of the sub-Pennsylvanian unconformity of the Arbuckle Group (Cambrian–Lower Ordovician): Kansas Geological Survey Open-File Report 2001-55, 2 sheets. http://www.kgs.ku.edu/PRS/publication/OFR2001-55/

Carr, J. E., McGovern, H. E., and Gogel, T., 1986, Geohydrology and potential for fluid disposal in the Arbuckle aquifer in Kansas: United States Geological Survey, Open-File Report no. 86-491, 101 p.

Carr, T. R., Merriam, D. F., and Bartley, J. D., 2005, Use of relational databases to evaluate regional petroleum accumulation, groundwater flow, and CO2 sequestration in Kansas: American Association of Petroleum Geologists, Bulletin, v. 89, no. 12, p. 1,607–1,627.

Conley, C. D., 1980, Petrology of Arbuckle Group, central Kansas (abs.): American Association of Petroleum Geologists, Bulletin, v. 64, no. 6, p. 960.

Crews, J., Mesko, T., and Kaden, S., 2010, Total dissolved solids concentrations of groundwater from the Ozark aquifer (Cambrian-Ordovician Systems) in Missouri: Missouri Department of Natural Resources, Geological Survey Program, Map OFM-10-571-GS.

Dahlberg, E. C., 1982, Applied Hydrodynamics in Petroleum Exploration: New York, Springer-Verlag, 161 p.

Doveton, J. H., 1986, Log Analysis of Subsurface Geology: New York, John Wiley & Sons, 273 p.

Earlougher, R. C., Jr., 1977, Advances in Well Test Analysis: New York, Society of Petroleum Engineers of AIME, 264 p.

Evans, C. S., and Newell, K. D., 2013, The Mississippian Limestone Play in Kansas: Oil and gas in a complex geologic setting: Kansas Geological Survey, Public Information Circular 33, 6 p.

Fazelalavi, M., 2015, Step-rate test, interference test results and DST results in Wellington: Kansas Geological Survey, Open-File Report, 2015-20, 12 p. http://www.kgs.ku.edu/Publications/OFR/2015/OFR2015_20.pdf

Franseen, E. K., Byrnes, A. P., Cansler, J. R., Steinhauff, D. M., and Carr, T. R., 2004, The geology of Kansas, Arbuckle Group: Kansas Geological Survey, Current Research in Earth Sciences, Bulletin 250, pt. 2. https://journals.ku.edu/mg/article/view/11789

Goebel, E. D, 1968, Cambrian System, in The Stratigraphic Succession in Kansas, D. E. Zeller, ed., p. 11–13: Kansas Geological Survey, Bulletin 89, 81 p.

Haworth, E., 1908, Special report on oil and gas: University Geological Survey of Kansas, v. 9, 586 p.

Horner, D. R., 1951, Pressure build-up in wells: Proceedings of the 3rd World Petroleum Congress, Section II, E.J. Brill, Leiden, Netherlands, p. 25–43.

Jorgensen, D. G., Helgesen, J. O., and Imes, J. L., 1993, Regional aquifers in Kansas, Nebraska, and parts of Arkansas, Colorado, Missouri, New Mexico, Oklahoma, South Dakota, Texas, and Wyoming; geohydrologic framework: United States Geological Survey, Professional Paper, no. 1414-B, 72 p. https://doi.org/10.3133/pp1414B

Jorgensen, D. G., Helgesen, J. O., Signor, D. C., Leonard, R. B., Imes, J. L., and Christenson, S. C., 1996, Analysis of regional aquifers in the central Midwest of the United States in Kansas, Nebraska, and parts of Arkansas, Colorado, Missouri, New Mexico, Oklahoma, South Dakota, Texas, and Wyoming; summary: United States Geological Survey, Professional Paper, no. 1414-A, 84 p. https://doi.org/10.3133/pp1414A

Kansas Geological Survey, 2018a, Oil and gas wells database. http://www.kgs.ku.edu/Magellan/Qualified/index.html

Kansas Geological Survey, 2018b, Search for brine analyses in Kansas. http://www.kgs.ku.edu/Magellan/Brine/index.html

Kansas Geological Survey, 2019, State production and historical info. http://www.kgs.ku.edu/PRS/petro/state.html

Macfarlane, P. A., and Hathaway, L. R., 1987, The hydrogeology and chemical quality of ground waters from the lower Paleozoic aquifers in the Tri-State region of Kansas, Missouri and Oklahoma: Kansas Geological Survey, Ground Water Series 9, 37 p.

Merriam, D. F., 1963, The geologic history of Kansas: Kansas Geological Survey, Bulletin 162, 317 p.

Newell, K. D., Bidgoli, T., Doveton, J. H., Whittemore, D., and Victorine, J., 2017, Water quality and flow in saltwater-containing formations in Kansas: Abstracts and Program, 2017 Governor’s Water Conference, Manhattan, Kansas: Kansas Water Office. https://kwo.ks.gov/docs/default-source/governor's-water-conference/2017-governor's-conference-presentations/newell---water-quality-and-flow.pdf?sfvrsn=20fe8714_2

Newell, K. D., Peterie, S., Killion, M., DeArmond, B., Ridley, C., Mandel, R., and Buchanan, R., 2019, Will the Arbuckle Group remain a viable disposal zone in Kansas?: Bulletin of the Kansas Geological Society, Wichita, Kansas, v. 94, no. 3, p. 14–20.

Peterie, S. L., Miller, R. D., Buchanan, R., and DeArmond, B., 2018, Fluid injection wells can have a wide seismic reach: EOS, 99. https://doi.org/10.1029/2018EO096199

Peterie, S. L., Miller, R. D., Intfen, J. E., and Gonzales, J. B., 2018, Earthquakes in Kansas induced by extremely far-field pressure: Geophysical Research Letters, v. 45, p. 1,395–1,401.

Pollyea, R. N., Mohammadi, N., Taylor, J. E., and Chapman, M. C., 2018, Geospatial analysis of Oklahoma (USA) earthquakes (2011–2016); quantifying the limits of regional earthquake mitigation: Geology, v. 46, p. 215–218.

Ramondetta, P. J., 1990, El Dorado — an old field with potential: Oil and Gas Journal, March 26, p. 110–116.

Scheffer, A., 2012, Geochemical and microbiological characterization of the Arbuckle saline aquifer, a potential CO2 storage reservoir; implications for hydraulic separation and caprock integrity: University of Kansas, Department of Geology, unpublished M.S. thesis, 82 p.

U. S. Energy Information Administration, 2019, Kansas crude oil first purchase price. https://www.eia.gov/dnav/pet/hist/LeafHandler.ashx?n=pet&s=f002020__3&f=m

U. S. Environmental Protection Agency, 2016, Underground injection control well classes. https://www.epa.gov/uic/underground-injection-control-well-classes

Wilkerson, T., 2017, 2017 pressure fall off and static fluid level test report, WWDW #1, Permit #KS-01-155-008: unpublished report by T&C Consulting for City of Hutchinson and Kansas Department of Health and Environment, 72 p.

Zerr, B., 2009, City of Hutchinson completes new reverse osmosis treatment plant: Kansas Rural Water Association, The Kansas Lifeline, November, p. 68–71. https://www.hungerfordterry.com/Hutchinson.pdf

Published
2020-06-30