Improving the standardization of wild bee occurrence data: Towards a formal wild bee data standard

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17161/jom.vi123.23163

Abstract

Conservation and management of wild bees is hindered by the variety of ways wild bee occurrence data are recorded, managed, and shared. Here, we present solutions to address this issue and introduce The Wild Bee Data Standard, a standardized means of recording and reporting data associated with wild bee occurrences, including physical specimens and photo observations. This standard aligns with contemporary data management practices widely adopted by the broader biodiversity data community. We propose a set of terms for the standard that describe various features of bee occurrences, including collection method and location, taxonomic verification, and final record storage. We emphasize the importance of providing sampling protocol and effort information with wild bee occurrence data and offer guidance to make this a more common practice. We describe how to translate data not currently aligned with the standard to meet its conditions, and how to upload those data to an accessible online repository. We provide case studies, data entry templates, a glossary of terms, and additional resources to guide new users to implementing the standard. We also present a forum, established as a GitHub repository, to support continued development of the standard. Recognizing the significant change this represents for current data practices, we outline the benefits for the bee research and conservation community that will result from improved data standards. We advocate for making all historical, current, and future bee occurrence data openly available to facilitate more rigorous and comprehensive research, conservation, and management of wild bees. This contribution is part of a series developed in association with the U.S. National Native Bee Monitoring Network to standardize bee monitoring practices.

References

A Collective and Ongoing Collaborative Effort by Those Who Love to Study Bees in North America. 2024. The Very Handy Bee Manual (2.0). Zenodo. [https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.12812755; last accessed October 2024.]

Bartomeus, I., J.R. Stavert, D. Ward, & O. Aguado. 2019. Historical collections as a tool for assessing the global pollination crisis. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B 374(1763): 20170389. https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.2017.0389

Bloom D.A., P. Zermoglio, & R. Guralnick. 2021. Analysis of biodiversity data needs in the post-2020 framework. Copenhagen: GBIF Secretariat. https://doi.org/10.35035/doc-2ph8-0403

Boone, M.L., Z.M. Portman, I. Lane, & S. Rao. 2023. Occupancy of Bombus affinis (Hymenoptera: Apidae) in Minnesota is highest in developed areas when standardized surveys are employed. Environmental Entomology 52(5): 918–938. https://doi.org/10.1093/ee/nvad088

Brand, A., L. Allen, M. Altman, M. Hlava, & J. Scott. 2015. Beyond authorship: Attribution, contribution, collaboration, and credit. Learned Publishing 28(2): 151–155. https://doi.org/10.1087/20150211

Briggs, E.L., C. Baranski, O. Münzer Schaetz, G. Garrison, J.A. Collazo, & E. Youngsteadt. 2022. Estimating bee abundance: can mark-recapture methods validate common sampling protocols? Apidologie 53(10). https://doi.org/10.1007/s13592-022-00919-4

Burkle, L.A., J.C. Knight, & T.M. Knight. 2013. Plant-pollinator interactions over 120 years: Loss of species, co-occurrence, and function. Science 339(6127): 1611–1615. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1232728

Burrows, S., C. Ritner, M. Christman, L. Spears, A. Smith-Pardo, S. Price, R. Ramirez, T. Griswold, & A. Redford. 2021. Exotic Bee ID: About bees. [https://idtools.org/exotic_bee/index.cfm?pageID=3064; accessed 14 June 2024.]

Campbell, C.J., V. Barve, M.W. Belitz, J.R. Doby, E. White, C. Seltzer, G. Di Cecco, A.H. Hurlbert, & R. Guralnick. 2023. Identifying the identifiers: How iNaturalist facilitates collaborative, research-relevant data generation and why it matters for biodiversity science. BioScience 73(7): 533–541. https://doi.org/10.1093/biosci/biad051

Cariveau, D.P., K.-L. Hung, N.M. Williams, D.W. Inouye, C.T. Burns, I. Lane, R. Irwin, H.K. Levenson, B. Du Clos, & S.H. Woodard. 2024. Standardized protocol for collecting plant-pollinator interaction data. Journal of Melittology 123(x): 1–x.

Carril, O., T. Griswold, & H.I. Ikerd. 2023. Wild bees of Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument: Richness, abundance, and spatio-temporal beta-diversity. PeerJ 6: e5867. https://doi.org/10.7717/peerj.5867 [Occurrence dataset accessed via GBIF.org on 2024-11-04]

Carroll, S.R., I. Garba, O.L. Figueroa-Rodríguez, J. Holbrook, R. Lovette, S. Materechera, M. Parsons, K. Raseroka, D. Rodriguez-Lonebear, R. Rowe, R. Sara, J.D. Walker, J. Anderson, & M. Hudson. 2020. The CARE Principles for Indigenous Data Governance. Data Science Journal 19(43): 1–12. https://doi.org/10.5334/dsj-2020-043.

Chesshire, P. 2023. Full Dataset prior to Cleaning. figshare. Dataset. https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.22455616.v1

Chesshire, P.R., E.E. Fischer, N.J. Dowdy, T.L. Griswold, A.C. Hughes, M.C. Orr, J.S. Ascher, L.M. Guzman, K.L.J. Hung, N.A. Cobb, & L.M. McCabe. 2023. Completeness analysis for over 3000 United States bee species identifies persistent data gap. Ecography 2023(5): e06584. https://doi.org/10.1111/ecog.06584

Cicero, C., M.S. Koo, E. Braker, J. Abbott, D. Bloom, M. Campbell, J.A. Cook, J.R. Demboski, A.C. Doll, L.M. Frederick, A.J. Linn, T.J. Mayfield-Meyer, D.L. McDonald, M.W. Nachman, L.E. Olson, D. Roberts, D.S. Sikes, C.C. Witt, & E.A. Wommack. 2024. Arctos: Community-driven innovations for managing natural and cultural history collections. PLoS ONE 19(5): e0296478. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0296478

Cobb, N.S., L.F. Gall, J.M. Zaspel, N.J. Dowdy, L.M. McCabe, & A.Y. Kawahara. 2019. Assessment of North American arthropod collections: Prospects and challenges for addressing biodiversity research. PeerJ 7: e8086 https://doi.org/10.7717/peerj.8086

Dorey, J.B., E.E. Fischer, P.R. Chesshire, A. Nava-Bolaños, R.L. O’Reilly, S. Bossert, S.M. Collins, E.M. Lichtenberg, E.M. Tucker, A. Smith-Pardo, A. Falcon-Brindis, D.A. Guevara, B. Ribeiro, D. de Pedro, J. Pickering, K.L.J. Hung, K.A. Parys, L.M. McCabe, M.S. Rogan, R.L. Minckley, S.J.E. Velazco, T. Griswold, T.A. Zarrillo, W. Jetz, Y.V. Sica, M.C. Orr, L.M. Guzman, J.S. Ascher, A.C. Hughes, & N.S. Cobb. 2023. A globally synthesised and flagged bee occurrence dataset and cleaning workflow. Scientific Data 10(747). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41597-023-02626-w

Droege. S., & C. Maffei. 2025. Insect species occurrence data from multiple projects worldwide with focus on bees and wasps in North America. Version 1.12. United States Geological Survey. Sampling event dataset. https://doi.org/10.15468/6autvb accessed via GBIF.org on 2025-02-14.

Du Clos, B., K.C. Seltmann, N.E. Turley, C. Maffei, E.M. Tucker, I.G. Lane, H.K. Levenson, & S.H. Woodard. 2025. Templates for The Wild Bee Data Standard (1.0.0). Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.14187861

Duke, C.S. & J.H. Porter. 2013. The ethics of data sharing and reuse in biology. BioScience 63(6): 483–489. https://doi.org/10.1525/bio.2013.63.6.10

GBIF.org (03 February 2021) GBIF Occurrence Download https://doi.org/10.15468/dl.6cxfsw

Graham, K.K., J. Gibbs., J. Wilson, E. May, & R. Isaacs. 2021. Resampling of wild bees across fifteen years reveals variable species declines and recoveries after extreme weather. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 317(107470). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agee.2021.107470

Graves, T.A., W.M. Janousek, S.M. Gaulke, A.C. Nicholas, D.A. Keinath, C.M. Bell, S. Cannings, R.G. Hatfield, J.M. Heron, J.B. Koch, H.L. Loffland, L.L. Richardson, A.T. Rohde, J. Rykken, J.P. Strange, L.M. Tronstad, & C.S. Sheffield. 2020. Western bumble bee: Declines in the continental United States and range-wide information gaps. Ecosphere 11(6): e03141. https://doi.org/10.1002/ecs2.3141

Gries, C., E. Gilbert, & N. Franz. 2014. Symbiota – A virtual platform for creating voucher-based biodiversity information communities. Biodiversity Data Journal 2: e1114. https://doi.org/10.3897/BDJ.2.e1114

Haak, L.L., M. Fenner., L. Paglione, E. Pentz, & H. Ratner. 2012. ORCID: A system to uniquely identify researchers. Learned Publishing 25(4): 259–264. https://doi.org/10.1087/20120404

Jones, M.B., M. O’Brien, B. Mecum, C. Boettiger, M. Schildhauer, M. Maier, T. Whiteaker, S. Earl, & S. Chong. 2019. Ecological Metadata Language version 2.2.0. KNB Data Repository. https://doi.org/10.5063/F11834T2

Ikerd, H. 2019. Bee Biology and Systematics Laboratory. USDA-ARS Pollinating Insect-Biology, Management, Systematics Research. Occurrence dataset https://doi.org/10.15468/anyror accessed via GBIF.org on 2024-11-04.

Lendemer. J., B. Thiers, A.K. Monfils, J. Zaspel, E.R. Ellwood, A. Bentley, K. LeVan, J. Bates, D. Jennings, D. Contreras, L. Lagomarsino, P. Mabee, L.S. Ford, R. Guralnick, R.E. Gropp, M. Revelez, N. Cobb, K. Seltmann, & M.C. Aime. 2020. The Extended Specimen Network: A strategy to enhance US biodiversity collections, promote research and education. BioScience 70(1): 23–30. https://doi.org/10.1093/biosci/bizl140

Levenson, H.K., B.N. Metz, & D.R. Tarpy. 2024a. Effects of study design parameters on estimates of bee abundance and richness in agroecosystems: A meta-analysis. Annals of the Entomological Society of America 117(2): 92–106. https://doi.org/10.1093/aesa/saae001

Levenson, H.K., O. Messinger Carril, N.E. Turley, C. Maffei, G. LeBuhn, T. Griswold, N.M. Williams, K.L.J. Hung, R.E. Irwin, B. Du Clos, & S.H. Woodard. 2024b. Standardized protocol for collecting community-level bee data. Journal of Melittology 123(4): 1–x.

Levenson, H.K., B. Du Clos, T.A. Smith, S. Jepsen, J.G. Everett, N.M. Williams, & S.H. Woodard. 2024c. A call for standardization in wild bee data collection and curation. Journal of Melittology 123(2): 4–17. https://doi.org/10.17161/jom.vi123.22533

López-Uribe, M.M., J.P. Strange, L. Whiteman, B.N. Danforth, S. Jha, M.G. Branstetter, J.B.U. Koch, H.K. Levenson, B. Du Clos, & S.H. Woodard. 2024. Standardized protocol for collecting bee samples to generate molecular data. Journal of Melittology 123(7): 1–x. https://doi.org/10.17161/jom.vi123.22596

MacPhail, V.J., R. Hatfield, & S.R. Colla. 2024. Bumble Bee Watch community science program increases scientific understanding of an important pollinator group across Canada and the USA. PLoS ONE 19(5): e0303335. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0303335

Martín-Mora, E., S. Ellis, & L.M. Page. 2020. Use of web-based species occurrence information systems by academics and government professionals. PLoS ONE 15(7): e0236556. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0236556.

Mathiasson, M.E., & S.M. Rehan. 2019. Status changes in the wild bees of north-eastern North America over 125 years revealed through museum specimens. Insect Conservation and Diversity 12(4): 278–288. https://doi.org/10.1111/icad.12347

Meineke, E.K., T.J. Davies, B.H. Daru, & C.C. Davis. 2018. Biological collections for understanding biodiversity in the Anthropocene. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B. 374(1763): 20170386. https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.2017.0386

Montgomery, G.A., M.W. Belitz, R.P. Guralnick, & M.W. Tingley. 2021. Standards and best practices for monitoring and benchmarking insects. Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution 8: 579193. https://doi.org/10.3389/fevo.2020.579193

Nachman, M.W., E.J. Beckman, R.C.K. Bowie, C. Cicero, C.J. Conroy, R. Dudley, T.B. Hayes, M.S. Koo, E.A. Lacey, C.H. Martin, J.A. McGuire, J.L. Patton, C.L. Spencer, R.D. Tarvin, M.H. Wake, I.J. Wang, A. Achmadi, S.T. Álvarez-Casteñeda, M.J. Anderson, J. Arroyave, C.C. Austin, F.K. Barker, L.N. Barrow, G.F. Barrowclough, J. Bates, A.M. Bauer, K.C. Bell, R.C. Bell, A.W. Bronson, R.M. Brown, F.T. Burbrink, K.J. Burns, C.D. Cadena, D.C. Cannatella, T.A. Castoe, P. Chakrabarty, J.P. Colella, J.A. Cook, J.L. Cracraft, D.R. Davis, A.R.D. Rabosky, G. D’Elìa, J.P. Dumbacher, J.L. Dunnum, S.V. Edwards, J.A. Esselstyn, J. Faivovish, J. Fjeldså, O.A. Flores-Villela, K. Ford, J. Fuchs, M.K. Fujita, J.M. Good, E. Greenbaum, H.W. Greene, S. Hackett, A. Hamidy, J. Hanken, T. Haryoko, M.T.R. Hawkins, L.R. Heaney, D.M. Hillis, B.D. Hollingsworth, A.D. Hornsby, P.A. Hosner, M. Irham, S. Jansa, R.A. Jiménez, L. Joseph, J.J. Kirchman, T.J. LaDuc, A.D. Leaché, E.P. Lessa, H. López-Fernández, N.A. Mason, J.E. McCormack, C.D. McMahan, R.G. Moyle, R.A. Ojeda, L.E. Olson, C.K. Onn, L.R. Parenti, G. Parra-Olea, B.D. Patterson, G.B. Pauly, S.E. Pavan, A.T. Peterson, S. Poe, D.L. Rabosky, C.J. Raxworthy, S. Reddy, A. Rico-Guevara, A. Riyanto, L.A. Rocha, S.R. Ron, S.M. Rovito, K.C. Rowe, J. Rowley, S. Ruane, D. Salazar-Valenzuela, A.J. Shultz, B. Sidlauskas, D.S. Sikes, N.B. Simmons, M.L.J. Stiassny, J.W. Streicher, B.L. Stuart, A.P. Summers, J. Tavera, P. Teta, C.W. Thompson, R.M. Timm, O. Torres-Carvajal, G. Voelker, R.S. Voss, K. Winker, C. Witt, E.A. Wommack, & R.M. Zink. 2023. Specimen collection is essential for modern science. PLoS Biology. 21(11): e3002318. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3002318

Nelson, A. 2022. Memorandum for the Heads of Executive Departments and Agencies: Ensuring Free, Immediate, and Equitable Access to Federally Funded Research. Executive Office of The President Office of Scientific Technology and Policy. 8 pp. https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/08-2022-OSTP-Public-Access-Memo.pdf. Accessed November 2024.

Nelson, G., & S. Ellis. 2018. The history and impact of digitization and digital data mobilization on biodiversity research. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B. 374: 20170391. https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.2017.0391

Orr, M.C., A.C. Hughes, D. Chesters, J. Pickering, C.D. Zhu, & J.S. Ascher. 2021. Global patterns and drivers of bee distribution. Current Biology 31(3): 451–458. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2020.10.053

Ostwald, M.M., V.H. Gonzalez, C. Chang, N. Vitale, M. Lucia, & K.C. Seltmann. 2024. Toward a functional trait approach to bee ecology. Ecology and Evolution 14(10): e70465. https://doi.org/10.1002/ece3.70465

Otto, C.R.V., L.L. Bailey, B. Du Clos, T. Smith, E. Evans, I. Pearse, S. Killingsworth, S. Jepsen, & S.H. Woodard. 2024. Estimating occupancy of focal bee species. Journal of Melittology 123(6): 1–x. https://doi.org/10.17161/jom.vi123.22555

Packer, L., Monckton, S.K., Onuferko, T.M., & R.R. Ferrari. 2018. Validating taxonomic identifications in entomological research. Insect Conservation and Diversity 11(1): 1–12. https://doi.org/10.1111/icad.12284

R Core Team. 2024. R: A language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria. https://www.R-project.org/

Robertson, T., M. Döring, R. Guralnick, D. Bloom, J. Wieczorek, K. Braak, J. Otegui, L. Russell, & P. Desmet. 2014. The GBIF Integrated Publishing Toolkit: Facilitating the efficient publishing of biodiversity data on the Internet. PLoS ONE 9(8): e102623. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0102623

Rousseau, J.S., S.H. Woodard, S.J. Jepsen, B. Du Clos, A. Johnston, B.N. Danforth, & A.D. Rodewald. 2024a. Advancing bee conservation in the US: Gaps and opportunities in data collection and reporting. Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution 12: 1346795. https://doi.org/10.3389/fevo.2024.1346795

Rousseau, J.S., A. Johnston, & A.D. Rodewald. 2024b. Indicators of a data-deficient taxa: Combining bird and environmental data enhances predictive accuracy of wild bee richness. bioRxiv. https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.02.14.580016

Seltmann, K., S. Lafia, D. Paul, S. James, D. Bloom, N. Rios, S. Ellis, U. Farrell, J. Utrup, M. Yost, E. Davis, R. Emery, G. Motz, J. Kimmig, V. Shirey, E. Sandall, D. Park, C. Tyrrell, R. Thackurdeen, M. Collins, V. O'Leary, H. Prestridge, C. Evelyn, & B. Nyberg. 2018. Georeferencing for Research Use (GRU): An integrated geospatial training paradigm for biocollections researchers and data providers. Research Ideas and Outcomes 4: e32449. https://doi.org/10.3897/rio.4.e32449

Seltmann, K. 2022. Natural history specimens collected and/or identified and deposited. Data set. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.6575038

Shorthouse, D.P. 2020. Bionomia: Linking natural history specimens to the world's collectors. https://bionomia.net.

Sigovini, M., E. Keppel, & D. Tagliapietra. 2016. Open nomenclature in the biodiversity era. Methods in Ecology and Evolution 7: 1216–1225. https://doi.org/10.1111/2041-210X.12594

Strange, J.P., M.M. López-Uribe, L. Whiteman, B.N. Danforth, S. Jha, H.K. Levenson, B. Du Clos, J.B.U. Koch, & S.H. Woodard. 2024. Standardized protocol for collecting bee samples for internal parasite and pathogen data. Journal of Melittology 123(8): 1–x. https://doi.org/10.17161/jom.vi123.22598

Strasser, C., R. Cook, W. Michener. & A. Budden. 2012. Primer on data management: What you always wanted to know. DataOne. https://doi.org/doi:10.5060/D2251G48

Thessen, A.E., M. Woodbrun, D. Koureas, D. Paul, M. Conlon, D.P. Shorthouse, & S. Ramdeen. 2019. Proper attribution for curation and maintenance of research collections: Metadata recommendations of the RDA/TDWG working group. Data Science Journal 18:54. https://doi.org/10.5334/dsj-2019-054

Turley, N.E., S.E. Kania, I.R. Petitta, E.A. Otruba, D.J. Biddinger, T.M. Butzler, V.V. Sesler, & M.M. López-Uribe. 2024. Bee monitoring by community scientists: Comparing a collections-based program with iNaturalist. Annals of the Entomological Society of America 117(4): 220–233. https://doi.org/10.1093/aesa/saae014

Turney, S., E.R. Cameron, C.A. Cloutier, & C.M. Buddle. 2015. Non-repeatable science: Assessing the frequency of voucher specimen deposition reveals that most arthropod research cannot be verified. PeerJ: 3:e1168. https://doi.org/10.7717/peerj.1168

Ulyshen, M., K. Elliott, J. Scott, S. Horn, P. Clinton, N. Liu, C.F. Miniat, P. Caldwell, C. Oishi, J. Knoepp, & P. Bolstad. 2022. Effects of Rhododendron removal and prescribed fire on bees and plants in the southern Appalachians. Ecology and Evolution 12(3): e8677. https://doi.org/10.1002/ece3.8677

US Fish and Wildlife Service. 2023. Biotic Observation Minimum Specification for FWS Inventory and Monitoring Surveys. [https://ecos.fws.gov/ServCat/Reference/Profile/153885; last accessed 14 June 2024.]

Wieczorek, J., D. Bloom, R. Guralnick, S. Blum, M. Döring, R. Giovanni, T. Robertson, & D. Vieglais. 2012. Darwin Core: An Evolving Community-Developed Biodiversity Data Standard. PLoS ONE 7(1): e29715. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0029715

Wilkinson, M., M. Dumontier, I.J. Aalbersberg, G. Appleton, M. Axton, A. Baak, N. Blomberg, J.W. Boiten, L.B. de Silva Santos, P.E. Bourne, J. Bouwman, A.J. Brookes, T. Clark, M. Crosas, I. Dillo, O. Dumon, S. Edmunds, C.T. Evelo, R. Finkers, A. Gonzalez-Beltran, A.J.G. Gray, P. Groth, C. Goble, J.S. Grethe, J. Heringa, P.A.C. Hoen, R. Hooft, T. Kuhn, R. Kok, J. Kok, S.J. Lusher, M.E. Martone, A. Mons, A.L. Packer, B. Persson, P. Rocca-Serra, M. Roos, R. van Schaik, S.A. Sansone, E. Schultes, T. Sengstag, T. Slater, G. Strawn, M.A. Swertz, M. Thompson, J. van der Lei, E. van Mulligen, J. Velterop, W. Waagmeester, P. Wittenberg, K. Wolstencroft, J. Zhao, & B. Mons. 2016. The FAIR guiding principles for scientific data management and stewardship. Scientific Data 3(160018). https://doi.org/10.1038/sdata.2016.18

Perdita cambarella

Downloads

Published

08-12-2025

How to Cite

Du Clos, B., Seltmann, K. C., Turley, N. E., Maffei, C., Tucker, E. M., Lane, I. G., Levenson, H. K., & Woodard, S. H. (2025). Improving the standardization of wild bee occurrence data: Towards a formal wild bee data standard. Journal of Melittology, 123. https://doi.org/10.17161/jom.vi123.23163

Most read articles by the same author(s)